chosemyshem wrote on 06 Jan 2025 16:17:
To amplify my previous post in response to a pm.
There's nothing wrong with yeshiva. I love yeshiva, and some of my best years were some of my days in yeshiva. I did not ch"v mean to put down the yeshiva system in any way.
What jumped out of me from the original post was a sense of life dissatisfaction. And I strongly identified with that feeling since I spent a heck of a lot of time in yeshiva feeling that way.
Riddled with desire, not willing to give into lust all the way but unable to stay away. Feeling stuck and sliding into mediocrity. Wishing I could either buckle down and shteig or give it up and party but instead caught in between in some hazy twilight of day to day mediocrity. Unfulfilled potential. Unfulfilled desires for spirituality and lust.
And then throw into the mix the societal pressure to get married. Wanting to get married but caught somewhere in a devil's threesome between wanting to use marriage to escape yeshiva, wanting to finally fulfill some of my desires, and truly wanting to build a bayis ne'eman byisroel with my soul mate.
All that, combined with not enough sleep and feeling like a sinner leaves a guy feeling pretty gross and repulsive. And that's just a drop in the bucket of many yeshiva guy's feelings.
Here's a theory. Many of those feelings arise out of the fact that many of us want to be in yeshiva, but we're not in yeshiva because of that. We're in yeshiva because it's the only viable option. And because we're not choosing to be there wholeheartedly we don't completely shtell tzu.
In yeshiva, it's so easy to float. I'm not saying that if you come to most of the sedarim, come to most of davenings then people will leave you alone (although that's often true). What I'm saying is you can come and participate but also not be totally involved. Instead, on some level, you're just hanging out and waiting for something that you "want" to start happening.
I'm meandering here. But long story short. If you're not choosing to live the life your living you're always going to feel that pull to other lives. And since most people in yeshiva are there because they're following the path of least resistance they feel pulled to other lives. (Again, they may well have chosen yeshiva if they had a choice. But they're not there by choice. They're there from the path of least resistance.)
And the solution is just to choose yeshiva. Get fully involved (I mean physically too, and from the actions will follow the heart, as the chinuch says.) Choose to live your life, and automatically the pull to other lives will lessen. It's not easy, but it's the best way through this feeling.
Just some thoughts. I apologize for the lack of clarity.
Love this post. I think its puts some clarity into many peoples yeshiva life