Yosef90 wrote on 16 Jun 2023 04:35:
Horizon wrote on 16 Jun 2023 01:34:
hi yosef90,
i think you made a good move by coming around here and posting. i have only positive things to say from my own experience doing so.
nice to hear that you have a productive life and are doing well. many of us live w this mistaken notion, that everything spins around this one, specific area. when we're successful w it we're fine no matter what our general life looks like, and if we're not doing well in this area, its game over even if we're being matzliach in so many different important areas. (i should credit @eerie for that thought).
i want to address a point you made at the end: i'm not boki in rambam or in chazal, but i have the chutzpa to say that hashem did not take your bechira away. i'm positive that hashem doesn't force a person to sin. (although לאחר המעשה there is an element of השגחה פרטית) ask your rav if you aint convinced but to me this is clear. i hope you'll excuse me for being this blunt.
hatzlacha in becoming a true yosef 90, and from there you'll slowly but surely go on to much much more
Thanks for the warm welcome. I remember hearing Rabbi YY Jacobson asking on the words we say in Mariv remove the Satan from before us and after us. Before us is simple we don't want to be tripped up. What is the after us? He answers that it's the Satan that tells us we are worthless because we sinned. We are not and its only the YH telling us we are.
Regarding Bechira I can try to find the source if you'd like but this is what I remember learning. I can handle blunt. There is an idea that we can loose Bechira. There are ways to get Bechira back of course and its not over until we're dead but it's harder once you've done an Avera over and over and over again, you need Hashem to help. It's a scary thought but it's the only thing that makes sense sometimes. I can be in a headspace where I know I'm going to control myself and then one small thing and I forget all my diversion tactics and slip up.
ah! thats a great vort. i recently heard a vort b' shem i forget which tzadik: it says in tehilim כי עוני אגיד אדעג מחטאתי. and the tzadik taitshed כי עוני אגיד, i will now announce my sins, the first of which is אדעג מחטאתי, i was saddened and felt lowly cuz of my sins.
since you can handle bluntness...
even by פרעה where the posuk says כי אני הכבדתי את לבו. the mifarshim ask how can it be that hashem takes away his bechira and then punishes him? (one explanation i remember hearing is that he already deserved the punishment for the prior enslavement of bnei yisroel).
in tanya he explains how hashem is חנון המרבה לסלוח. this is where we see the gadlus of hashem, that unlike humans who wouldnt be able to forgive if someone repeatedly bothered him, hashem is מרבה לסלוח. moreover: a yid asked in shacharis slach lonu, and then a couple hours later by mincha is again asking for slicha... and on that we say חנון המרבה לסלוח.
anyway excuse me for getting technical. the main thing is you gotta believe you can do this, (with hashems help of course) and you'll hear from people here who have truly broken free. i wish you tons a luck going onward