Welcome tzaddik!
Mazel Tov on your 9 day streak! I can definitely relate to such a "small" number being
huge.
And the "Why not"? completely normal, for sure in the beginning of trying to figure out what's going on with this habit/pacifier- cuz that's mostly what it is. I found that working on motivation/reasons for change, connection here in the Forum, and having a Mentor really helped.
That "Pink cloud" stage? "I'm never gonna fall again, 30/40/90 days plus, I got this, I realize now that I don't want this and I have all this support, it's gonna be easy" and then Boom, it's back, "what happened? why did I do that? Oh well, guess I was wrong about this being possible, I'll just do it again..."
Also normal! This is how the most rewarding journey of your life starts.
Having an accountability partner or Mentor really helps me with this part. Calling him and saying "I just fell... I feel like a failure, I was doing so good..." He gets me back up to keep going and not do it again. Even knowing I'm gonna have to call him after I fall can push off the fall entirely.
Or at least not make me do it twice cuz it's a lot easier to explain why I fell once rather than twice in a row...
Why would you want "guilty" feelings. Guilty" feelings are not good. That's part of what causes the "Oh, I'll just do it again".
Healthy feelings of "That was a wrong thing to do, and bad for me, but I will get up and keep going" is good.
Point is: Your perfectly normal and you're doing amazing!
Actually, you're way better than normal, cuz you're fighting against what the whole outside world is trying to tell you to keep doing and go along with!
Keep posting about your ups and downs, we're here with you every step of the way!
CHAZAK V'EMATZ!!